Dear Miss Zhang,
Re: "Effect of arbitrary dust size distribution on envelope wave packet in unmagnetized dusty plasma." by Zhang, Xiao xue; Lin, Mai-Mai; Du, Haisu
Article reference: PHYSSCR-104114
Your Paper has now been considered by the Editorial Board of Physica Scripta and the Board Member's report can be found below.
We regret to inform you that the Board Member has recommended that your article should not be published in the journal, for the reasons given in the enclosed report. Your manuscript has therefore been withdrawn from consideration.
We would like to thank you for your interest in Physica Scripta.
Yours sincerely
Yasmin McGlashan
Publishing Team
Yasmin McGlashan - Publisher
Emma Chorlton, Claire Fullarton & Miriam Howland - Publishing Editors
Zora Catterick - Publishing Administrator
Chris Benson - Production Editor
physscr@iop.org
IOP Publishing
Temple Circus, Temple Way, Bristol
BS1 6HG, UK
www.iopscience.org/physscr
2014 Impact Factor = 1.126
COMMENTS FROM EDITORIAL BOARD:
Associate Editor
Comments to the Author:
This paper is poorly written, consisting of a patchwork of phrases that appear to have been copied from other people's papers. It is also of low interest to the general readers of Physica Scripta, who expect to encounter papers presenting significant advances of interest to the broad community. The authors are advised to rewrite the paper prior to submitting it elsewhere.
Letter reference: DSR08